ADVERTISEMENT
  • PT Insider
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • PT Hausa
  • About Us
  • PT Jobs
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Store
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Premium Times Nigeria
  • Home
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Investigations
    • All
    • Alabuga Reports
    • Blood on Uniforms
    OAU Primary Health Centre, Ojoku, during PREMIUM TIMES’ return visit on 6 May 2026. The exterior had been painted and the roof, doors and windows were in place, but no clinical services were being provided.

    Kogi announces ₦7 billion upgrade of PHCs but won’t provide details while clinics remain incomplete, understaffed

    TELA maize from cultivation to consumption. (PHOTO CREDIT: Mariya Shuaibu Suleiman)

    SPECIAL REPORT: What are Nigerians eating? Tracing TELA maize from farms to dinner tables (I)

    Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka, who was shot dead alongside Adamu Abubakar in Dutsin-Ma, Katsina State, on 26 October 2026. Credit: Ogalah Dunamis/PREMIUM TIMES

    A Forgotten Bag, Four Gunshots: Sheikh Masussuka’s final evening

    St Martin de Porres School

    SPECIAL REPORT: Beyond tuition, extra school charges deepen financial strain on Nigerian parents

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Gas Flare at Obagi flare stack 1

    PREMIUM TIMES investigates TotalEnergies’ ‘zero routine flaring’ claim

    Atiku, Ribadu, Fintiri, Binani, Haske, and Ishaku Abbo

    2027: Fintiri’s exit, Atiku, Ribadu’s interests set stage for tight Adamawa governorship race

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: How Anthony Kila falsified all his academic qualifications – from Bachelor’s to Doctorate

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: The fake professor leading a Nigerian university

  • Business
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Business Specials
    • Trade Insights
    • Opinion
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Columns
    • Contributors
    • Editorial
    “Coconut Judge”: When ambiguity becomes misconduct, By Stephen Kola-Balogun

    “Coconut Judge”: When ambiguity becomes misconduct, By Stephen Kola-Balogun

    Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

    Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

    AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

    Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

    AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

  • Health
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Health Specials
    • Features and Interviews
    • Multimedia
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Τα Καλύτερα Online Casino
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential
    • Gubernatorial
  • Home
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Investigations
    • All
    • Alabuga Reports
    • Blood on Uniforms
    OAU Primary Health Centre, Ojoku, during PREMIUM TIMES’ return visit on 6 May 2026. The exterior had been painted and the roof, doors and windows were in place, but no clinical services were being provided.

    Kogi announces ₦7 billion upgrade of PHCs but won’t provide details while clinics remain incomplete, understaffed

    TELA maize from cultivation to consumption. (PHOTO CREDIT: Mariya Shuaibu Suleiman)

    SPECIAL REPORT: What are Nigerians eating? Tracing TELA maize from farms to dinner tables (I)

    Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka, who was shot dead alongside Adamu Abubakar in Dutsin-Ma, Katsina State, on 26 October 2026. Credit: Ogalah Dunamis/PREMIUM TIMES

    A Forgotten Bag, Four Gunshots: Sheikh Masussuka’s final evening

    St Martin de Porres School

    SPECIAL REPORT: Beyond tuition, extra school charges deepen financial strain on Nigerian parents

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Gas Flare at Obagi flare stack 1

    PREMIUM TIMES investigates TotalEnergies’ ‘zero routine flaring’ claim

    Atiku, Ribadu, Fintiri, Binani, Haske, and Ishaku Abbo

    2027: Fintiri’s exit, Atiku, Ribadu’s interests set stage for tight Adamawa governorship race

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: How Anthony Kila falsified all his academic qualifications – from Bachelor’s to Doctorate

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: The fake professor leading a Nigerian university

  • Business
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Business Specials
    • Trade Insights
    • Opinion
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Columns
    • Contributors
    • Editorial
    “Coconut Judge”: When ambiguity becomes misconduct, By Stephen Kola-Balogun

    “Coconut Judge”: When ambiguity becomes misconduct, By Stephen Kola-Balogun

    Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

    Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

    AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

    Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

    AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

  • Health
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Health Specials
    • Features and Interviews
    • Multimedia
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Τα Καλύτερα Online Casino
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential
    • Gubernatorial
Premium Times Nigeria
BUA Group Ad BUA Group Ad BUA Group Ad

“Coconut Judge”: When ambiguity becomes misconduct, By Stephen Kola-Balogun

If “coconut” means hard, unyielding, a hard nut to crack, then Kalu was criticising a judgment. And criticising a judgment, even in strong language, is not misconduct. It is the duty of a lawyer.

byPremium Times
November 21, 2026
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
Google Logo Add us on Google
Justice Lifu

The NBA is right that lawyers must treat courts with respect. The ADC is right that the NBA is not a political party. Both can be true. The way to reconcile them is not to punish ambiguity. It is to hear the explanation. Bentley was hanged on four ambiguous words. It took 45 years to correct that mistake. We should not need 45 years to learn the lesson: when words can bear two meanings, the law must not choose the worse one and punish the speaker for it.

The Kalu Kalu charge, R v. Bentley, and Why the LPDC Should Not Sustain It

Join the Premium Times WhatsApp Community For Quick Access To News and Happenings Around You.

Open in WhatsApp

Background

FIRST BANK AD Do you live in Ogijo

On 11th November, lawyer Kalu Kalu appeared on Channels Television’s “Politics Today” to discuss Justice Peter O Lifu’s judgment of 5th November, which nullified the David Mark-led leadership of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and the decisions taken under it. He argued that the judgment did not expressly invalidate Atiku Abubakar’s presidential nomination, and in the course of that argument he called Justice Lifu a “coconut judge.” The presenter, Seun Okinbaloye, interrupted him and asked him to withdraw the remark, to which Kalu replied: “Because of time, I do withdraw it.”

On 13th November, the NBA President, Oyinkansola Badejo-Okusanya (SAN) forwarded a petition, with the broadcast recording, to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) for alleged disparaging remarks against a sitting judge. The NBA was careful to add that this is not a finding. Kalu will have a chance to respond. The LPDC will decide. On the material in the public domain, that charge cannot be reasonably sustained, for three reasons: ambiguity, context, and perception.

Ambiguity

What does “coconut judge” mean? The petition appears to proceed on one meaning only: that it is an insult. But “coconut” is a metaphor, and metaphors are ambiguous. In Nigerian speech, a coconut is hard on the outside, and thus hard to crack. A “hard nut to crack” means someone who is stubborn, unyielding, unmovable, and difficult to persuade. If Kalu meant that Justice Lifu is a hard nut to crack as a judge who, once he has taken a view, will not shift, that is not a personal insult. That is a criticism of judicial temperament and reasoning. Lawyers criticise judgments in strong language every day. That is not misconduct. That is advocacy. The LPDC must prove what Kalu intended, and that the words could only bear an insulting meaning. They cannot. This is the lesson of R v. Bentley (Deceased) [1998] EWCA Crim 2516.

PT WHATSAPP CHANNEL
Dangote Refinery AD

In 1952, Derek Bentley, 19, was on a roof with Christopher Craig, 16, during a burglary. Police said Bentley shouted: “Let him have it, Chris.” The prosecution said it meant: “Shoot him, Chris.” The defence said it could mean: “Give him the gun, Chris surrender it.” The jury adopted the prosecution’s meaning. Bentley, who never fired a shot, was convicted of murder and hanged in 1953, despite the jury’s recommendation of mercy. In 1998, the Court of Appeal quashed the conviction. Lord Bingham held that Bentley had been denied a fair trial. The trial judge had failed to direct the jury properly on the burden of proof, on joint enterprise, and on the possible ambiguity of “Let him have it.” Bentley teaches what applies directly to Kalu: first, words do not have one meaning.

Premium Times

Stay Ahead with Premium Times

Follow us on Google News and never miss breaking stories, investigations, and in-depth reporting.

Google Logo Add as a preferred source on Google

The LPDC must allow Kalu to do what television did not allow: explain in full what he meant. In June, the Court of Appeal described Justice Lifu’s conduct in the ADC deregistration case as “judicial impertinence” and “judicial rascality.” On 28 July, it overturned the deregistration. Those are far stronger words than “coconut.” They were institutional criticism of conduct in a judgment, and they were justified. Kalu is entitled to argue that his comment was of the same order…

Context

Second: Context is everything. Bentley was already under arrest when the words were allegedly spoken. Kalu was in the middle of a legal argument about what the 5th November judgment actually decided. The speaker must be heard on what he meant.

Much has been made of the withdrawal, as if it were a confession. It was not. Read it literally: “Because of time, I do withdraw it.” On live television, time is controlled by the presenter, not the guest. When the presenter says, “Withdraw it,” and the guest says, “Because of time, I withdraw it,” he is saying: I do not have time to explain what I meant, so I will withdraw the phrase to allow the programme to continue. That is not an admission that the phrase was insulting. It is a concession to the clock. To treat a time-pressured withdrawal as proof of guilty intent would repeat Bentley’s error to take a fragment of a speech, strip it of context, and give it the worst possible meaning.

The LPDC must allow Kalu to do what television did not allow: explain in full what he meant. In June, the Court of Appeal described Justice Lifu’s conduct in the ADC deregistration case as “judicial impertinence” and “judicial rascality.” On 28 July, it overturned the deregistration. Those are far stronger words than “coconut.” They were institutional criticism of conduct in a judgment, and they were justified. Kalu is entitled to argue that his comment was of the same order: criticism of a judgment, not an attack on the man. The ADC’s question, “What has Kalu said that the Court of Appeal has not already said?” is rhetorical, but it makes a serious point about proportionality.

…in law, as we are taught by R v. Sussex Justices ex p Mc Carthy (1923) All ER Rep 233, justice must not only be done, but must manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done. Kalu was commenting on that sequence, in the heat of the moment, on live television, without time to elaborate. To discipline him for that while questions about assignment and perception remain unanswered by the National Judicial Council risks creating a second perception: that the Bar is quicker to punish the lawyer who complains about the process than to investigate the process itself.

Perception

This charge does not arise in a vacuum. The ADC leadership case began on 2nd September 2025 before Justice Emeka Nwite. It was reassigned to Justice Lifu. The Chief Judge, Justice John Tsoho, explained the reassignment by Nwite’s elevation, but gave no reason why it had to be Lifu, who was already handling the ADC deregistration case. He delivered judgment in three days after the Court of Appeal stayed it. On 1st June, ADC National Secretary Rauf Aregbesola wrote objecting to the reassignment and expressing lack of confidence in Lifu. The case was assigned to Lifu the next day. On 5th November, Lifu nullified the Mark leadership and its decisions.

That is the sequence that creates the perception of bias not proof of bias, but the appearance that a fair-minded observer would find troubling. And in law, as we are taught by R v. Sussex Justices ex p Mc Carthy (1923) All ER Rep 233, justice must not only be done, but must manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done. Kalu was commenting on that sequence, in the heat of the moment, on live television, without time to elaborate. To discipline him for that while questions about assignment and perception remain unanswered by the National Judicial Council risks creating a second perception: that the Bar is quicker to punish the lawyer who complains about the process than to investigate the process itself.

Conclusion

The NBA is right that lawyers must treat courts with respect. The ADC is right that the NBA is not a political party. Both can be true. The way to reconcile them is not to punish ambiguity. It is to hear the explanation. Bentley was hanged on four ambiguous words. It took 45 years to correct that mistake. We should not need 45 years to learn the lesson: when words can bear two meanings, the law must not choose the worse one and punish the speaker for it. If “coconut” means hard, unyielding, a hard nut to crack, then Kalu was criticising a judgment. And criticising a judgment, even in strong language, is not misconduct. It is the duty of a lawyer – R v. Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis, ex p. Blackburn [1968] 2 QB 118.

Stephen Kola-Balogun is a legal practitioner based in Lagos.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print

Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Previous Post

2027: Abiodun says investors bet on Ogun’s political stability, governance continuity

Premium Times

Premium Times

More News

Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

November 20, 2026
Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

November 19, 2026
Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

November 19, 2026
Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

November 19, 2026
Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

November 18, 2026
Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

November 18, 2026
Leave Comment

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Our Digital Network

  • PT Hausa
  • Election Centre
  • Human Trafficking Investigation
  • Centre for Investigative Journalism
  • National Conference
  • Press Attack Tracker
  • PT Academy
  • Dubawa
  • LeaksNG
  • Campus Reporter

Resources

  • Oil & Gas Facts
  • List of Universities in Nigeria
  • LIST: Federal Unity Colleges in Nigeria
  • NYSC Orientation Camps in Nigeria
  • Nigeria’s Federal/States’ Budgets since 2005
  • Malabu Scandal Thread
  • World Cup 2018
  • Panama Papers Game

Projects & Partnerships

  • AUN-PT Data Hub
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • Parliament Watch
  • Panama Papers
  • AGAHRIN
  • #PandoraPapers
  • #ParadisePapers
  • #SuisseSecrets
  • Our Digital Network
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Resources
  • Projects
  • Data & Infographics
  • DONATE

All content is Copyrighted © 2025 The Premium Times, Nigeria

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

DMCA.com Protection Status
  • Home
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential & NASS
    • Gubernatorial & State House
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Investigations
  • Business
    • Gender
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Trade Insights
    • Business Specials
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Health
    • COVID-19
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Data and Infographics
    • Health Specials
    • Features
    • Events
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Research & Innovation
    • Data & Infographics
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • AUN-PT Data Hub
  • Projects
    • Panama Papers
    • Paradise Papers
    • SuisseSecrets
    • Parliament Watch
    • AGAHRIN
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
  • PT Hausa
  • Become a PT Insider
  • DONATE
  • About Us
  • Dubawa NG
  • Advert Rates
  • PT Jobs
  • Digital Store
  • Contact Us

All content is Copyrighted © 2025 The Premium Times, Nigeria

Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading