ADVERTISEMENT
  • PT Insider
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • PT Hausa
  • About Us
  • PT Jobs
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Store
Friday, November 20, 2026
Premium Times Nigeria
  • Home
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Investigations
    • All
    • Alabuga Reports
    • Blood on Uniforms
    OAU Primary Health Centre, Ojoku, during PREMIUM TIMES’ return visit on 6 May 2026. The exterior had been painted and the roof, doors and windows were in place, but no clinical services were being provided.

    Kogi announces ₦7 billion upgrade of PHCs but won’t provide details while clinics remain incomplete, understaffed

    TELA maize from cultivation to consumption. (PHOTO CREDIT: Mariya Shuaibu Suleiman)

    SPECIAL REPORT: What are Nigerians eating? Tracing TELA maize from farms to dinner tables (I)

    Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka, who was shot dead alongside Adamu Abubakar in Dutsin-Ma, Katsina State, on 26 October 2026. Credit: Ogalah Dunamis/PREMIUM TIMES

    A Forgotten Bag, Four Gunshots: Sheikh Masussuka’s final evening

    St Martin de Porres School

    SPECIAL REPORT: Beyond tuition, extra school charges deepen financial strain on Nigerian parents

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Gas Flare at Obagi flare stack 1

    PREMIUM TIMES investigates TotalEnergies’ ‘zero routine flaring’ claim

    Atiku, Ribadu, Fintiri, Binani, Haske, and Ishaku Abbo

    2027: Fintiri’s exit, Atiku, Ribadu’s interests set stage for tight Adamawa governorship race

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: How Anthony Kila falsified all his academic qualifications – from Bachelor’s to Doctorate

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: The fake professor leading a Nigerian university

  • Business
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Business Specials
    • Trade Insights
    • Opinion
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Columns
    • Contributors
    • Editorial
    Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

    Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

    AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

    Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

    AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

    Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

    Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

  • Health
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Health Specials
    • Features and Interviews
    • Multimedia
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Τα Καλύτερα Online Casino
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential
    • Gubernatorial
  • Home
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Investigations
    • All
    • Alabuga Reports
    • Blood on Uniforms
    OAU Primary Health Centre, Ojoku, during PREMIUM TIMES’ return visit on 6 May 2026. The exterior had been painted and the roof, doors and windows were in place, but no clinical services were being provided.

    Kogi announces ₦7 billion upgrade of PHCs but won’t provide details while clinics remain incomplete, understaffed

    TELA maize from cultivation to consumption. (PHOTO CREDIT: Mariya Shuaibu Suleiman)

    SPECIAL REPORT: What are Nigerians eating? Tracing TELA maize from farms to dinner tables (I)

    Sheikh Yahaya Ibrahim Masussuka, who was shot dead alongside Adamu Abubakar in Dutsin-Ma, Katsina State, on 26 October 2026. Credit: Ogalah Dunamis/PREMIUM TIMES

    A Forgotten Bag, Four Gunshots: Sheikh Masussuka’s final evening

    St Martin de Porres School

    SPECIAL REPORT: Beyond tuition, extra school charges deepen financial strain on Nigerian parents

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Stalled wind farm project in Katsina typifies Nigeria’s struggle to build renewable-energy industry

    Gas Flare at Obagi flare stack 1

    PREMIUM TIMES investigates TotalEnergies’ ‘zero routine flaring’ claim

    Atiku, Ribadu, Fintiri, Binani, Haske, and Ishaku Abbo

    2027: Fintiri’s exit, Atiku, Ribadu’s interests set stage for tight Adamawa governorship race

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: How Anthony Kila falsified all his academic qualifications – from Bachelor’s to Doctorate

    Anthony Kila

    INVESTIGATION: The fake professor leading a Nigerian university

  • Business
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Business Specials
    • Trade Insights
    • Opinion
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Columns
    • Contributors
    • Editorial
    Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

    Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

    Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

    Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

    AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

    Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

    AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

    Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

    Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

  • Health
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Health Specials
    • Features and Interviews
    • Multimedia
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Τα Καλύτερα Online Casino
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential
    • Gubernatorial
Premium Times Nigeria
BUA Group Ad BUA Group Ad BUA Group Ad

Why Nigeria’s election petition system is unconstitutional, By Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

It is problematic enough that judges have now overthrown popular sovereignty as the basis of the mandate to rule in Nigeria and substituted it with a grandiloquent notion of judicial sovereignty.

byPremium Times
July 13, 2025
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
Google Logo Add us on Google

In Nigeria where the decision on whom to confer the mandate to rule has been relocated by fiat of the Supreme Court from the ballot box to the court room, citizens are currently denied standing to participate in disputes involving the identity or determination of the person or party on whom they have conferred that mandate. The surprise is that no one has sought to bring this to the attention of the courts as such or challenge the lawfulness or constitutionality of this fundamental design flaw in Nigeria’s election petition system.

“Sovereignty belongs to the people of Nigeria from whom government through this Constitution derives all its powers and authority.” – Section 14(2), Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999

Join the Premium Times WhatsApp Community For Quick Access To News and Happenings Around You.

Open in WhatsApp

In 2007, the contest to rule Nigeria was between two sons of Katsina State. From the Katsina Emirate, Umaru Musa Yar’Adua ran on the ticket of the then ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) to succeed outgoing President Olusegun Obasanjo. His elder brother, Shehu, had served as Obasanjo’s second-in-command during military rule from February 1976 to October 1979. From the Daura Emirate, also in Katsina State, Muhammadu Buhari, who also served alongside Obasanjo and Shehu Musa Yar’Adua in that military government, was the leading opposition candidate on the platform of the All Nigeria Peoples’ Party (ANPP).

FIRST BANK AD Do you live in Ogijo

The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) announced Umaru Musa Yar’Adua as winner and Muhammadu Buhari lodged a petition to challenge the declaration. After a prolonged period of litigation, the Supreme Court handed down its decision on 12 December 2008 by a narrow majority dismissing Muhammadu Buhari’s petition.

Of the many things pronounced upon by the court, two stood out. One was its refusal to affirm any set of principles to govern the conduct of elections in Nigeria. The other was the formal pronouncement in the leading judgment of Niki Tobi that in elections in the country, “the judges must be the final bus-stop.” A report on election dispute resolution in Nigeria published earlier this year by the Policy and Legislative Advocacy Centre (PLAC) reinforced this, declaring that the electoral process in Nigeria has now been formally relocated “from ballot to the courts.”

The idea of judges as the “final bus-stop” for the determination of electoral legitimacy in the Nigeria sounds like a wanton departure from the clear constitutional design, which confers sovereignty upon the people, “from whom government through this constitution derives all its powers and authority.” Judges may be people in the sense of human beings like every other citizen, but as a conclave of decision makers in a court, they are not the people upon whom the constitution confers the mandate to decide who rules the country.

PT WHATSAPP CHANNEL

When it comes to contests over elections in Nigeria, the Electoral Act does not provide any room for the people whose mandate is at stake to participate in disputes over the destination of their mandate or what happens to it.

Dangote Refinery AD

There was nothing inexorable about the order made by the Supreme Court in this case. The court could have invalidated the primaries of the APC. Indeed, it could still arguably have excluded the APC from the contest. But faced with the reality of excluding over two-thirds of the voters of the state from having a say in who governs them, the structure, text and spirit of both the constitution and the idea of government founded on the will of the people required the Supreme Court in that case to do only one thing – order a re-run…

It is problematic enough that judges have now overthrown popular sovereignty as the basis of the mandate to rule in Nigeria and substituted it with a grandiloquent notion of judicial sovereignty. The case of the Zamfara State governorship election of 2019 demonstrates how dangerously self-regarding judicial sovereignty has become in Nigeria.

Premium Times

Stay Ahead with Premium Times

Follow us on Google News and never miss breaking stories, investigations, and in-depth reporting.

Google Logo Add as a preferred source on Google

In that year, Mukhtar Shehu Idris, the candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC), secured a total of 534,541 votes or 67.41 per cent of the votes cast to win the contest for the office of governor of Zamfara State. He clearly won the vote in each and all of the 14 Local Government Areas of the state. In a distant second was Bello Matawalle of the PDP, who secured 189,452 votes or 23.89 per cent of the votes cast, less than 25 per cent of the votes cast in the state. Mattawalle also lost in every Local Government Area in the state.

Preceding the vote, however, the contest for the ticket of the APC was the subject of competing and contradictory orders from various courts in the country, both state and federal. Nobody alleged that the result was anything other than the manifest will of the people. But in resolving the complicated pre-election litigation on 24 May 2019, the Supreme Court invalidated the APC primaries, disbarred the candidate from the contest retrospectively and pronounced that “this being so, the votes credited to the [APC candidates] in the 2019 general elections in Zamfara State are wasted votes.”

Not content with throwing the votes of more than two-thirds of the voters of the state into the dust bin, the Supreme Court went further and pronounced as the winner, Bello Matawalle, who had been beaten hopelessly into an insignificant second position. This was election robbery under the ruse of jurisprudence.

There was nothing inexorable about the order made by the Supreme Court in this case. The court could have invalidated the primaries of the APC. Indeed, it could still arguably have excluded the APC from the contest. But faced with the reality of excluding over two-thirds of the voters of the state from having a say in who governs them, the structure, text and spirit of both the constitution and the idea of government founded on the will of the people required the Supreme Court in that case to do only one thing – order a re-run so that the people of Zamfara State could look at the candidate on offer and choose who to rule them. Instead the court chose to supplant popular sovereignty with judicial sovereignty, infantilise the voters and install as governor for the people of Zamfara State, a person whom they looked at and roundly rejected at the polls.

…when the Supreme Court decided in 2019 that the votes of a super-majority of the people of Zamfara State in the governorship election were “wasted”, it did not bother to hear from any of the affected voters or their legal representatives. In Plateau State, where a judicial hit-squad from the Court of Appeal did something similar to the voters in the legislative elections in 2023, again, the people could not be represented. 

At the beginning of January 2008, Nigeria’s Supreme Court decided in the case that ultimately handed the office of the Governor of Rivers State to Chibuike Rotimi Amaechi that under Nigeria’s constitution, it is the political party alone that contests or wins an election. However, in a little-noticed line in that judgment, Adesola Oguntade, who delivered the judgment of the court, cautioned that law governing political or election dispute resolution in the Nigerian constitution and law was “intended to ensure a smooth transition from one administration to another. It is not a provision to destroy the right of access to the court granted to a citizen under section 36 of the same Constitution.”

The basic requirement of section 36 of the Constitution is a guarantee that a person or group whose “civil rights and obligations” are liable to be determined in a court of law, “shall be entitled to a fair hearing within a reasonable time by a court or other tribunal established by law and constituted in such manner as to secure its independence and impartiality.” In a system of government founded on one person one vote, no civil right or obligation competes for primacy on an equal footing with the right of citizens to choose who governs them or how to constitute their government.

Yet, when the Supreme Court decided in 2019 that the votes of a super-majority of the people of Zamfara State in the governorship election were “wasted”, it did not bother to hear from any of the affected voters or their legal representatives. In Plateau State, where a judicial hit-squad from the Court of Appeal did something similar to the voters in the legislative elections in 2023, again, the people could not be represented. It is difficult to contemplate a clearer violation of section 36 of the Constitution.

In Nigeria where the decision on whom to confer the mandate to rule has been relocated by fiat of the Supreme Court from the ballot box to the court room, citizens are currently denied standing to participate in disputes involving the identity or determination of the person or party on whom they have conferred that mandate. The surprise is that no one has sought to bring this to the attention of the courts as such or challenge the lawfulness or constitutionality of this fundamental design flaw in Nigeria’s election petition system. The main objection to this is that it could be both confounding and inconvenient to ask potentially millions of voters to join in such proceedings. We will address this objection fully next.

Chidi Anselm Odinkalu, a lawyer, teaches at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy and can be reached through [email protected].

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print

Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Previous Post

The rotten apples at Louis Edet House, By Festus Adedayo

Next Post

Court didn’t order us to reinstate Akpoti-Uduaghan, Senate says

Premium Times

Premium Times

More News

Friday Sermon: Nyesom Wike, AM Yarima and the display of bravery, courage and self-respect!, By Murtadha Gusau

Friday Sermon: Listen to the cries of Nigerians before the door closes!, By Murtadha Gusau

November 20, 2026
Azu Ishiekwene writes about Muhammadu Buhari and his legacy.

Pre-election absurdities take on a new life, By Azu Ishiekwene

November 19, 2026
Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

Holding Hamzat to his P.R.O.M.I.S.E, By Semiu Okanlawon

November 19, 2026
Ehi Braimah writes about Ken-Calebs Olumese at 80.

AfCFTA: Afreximbank and AfDB must drive Africa’s economic integration, By Ehi Braimah

November 19, 2026
Zainab Suleiman Okino writes about Sule Lamido and his new biography.

AI’s interference in elections now takes the centre stage, By Zainab Suleiman Okino

November 18, 2026
Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

Nigeria’s politics of fear: Who profits when democracy bleeds?, By Jude Dike

November 18, 2026

  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Our Digital Network

  • PT Hausa
  • Election Centre
  • Human Trafficking Investigation
  • Centre for Investigative Journalism
  • National Conference
  • Press Attack Tracker
  • PT Academy
  • Dubawa
  • LeaksNG
  • Campus Reporter

Resources

  • Oil & Gas Facts
  • List of Universities in Nigeria
  • LIST: Federal Unity Colleges in Nigeria
  • NYSC Orientation Camps in Nigeria
  • Nigeria’s Federal/States’ Budgets since 2005
  • Malabu Scandal Thread
  • World Cup 2018
  • Panama Papers Game

Projects & Partnerships

  • AUN-PT Data Hub
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • Parliament Watch
  • Panama Papers
  • AGAHRIN
  • #PandoraPapers
  • #ParadisePapers
  • #SuisseSecrets
  • Our Digital Network
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Resources
  • Projects
  • Data & Infographics
  • DONATE

All content is Copyrighted © 2025 The Premium Times, Nigeria

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

DMCA.com Protection Status
  • Home
  • Elections
    • 2024 Ondo Governorship Election
    • 2024 Edo Governorship Election
    • Presidential & NASS
    • Gubernatorial & State House
  • News
    • Headline Stories
    • Top News
    • More News
    • Foreign
  • Investigations
  • Business
    • Gender
    • News Reports
    • Financial Inclusion
    • Analysis and Data
    • Trade Insights
    • Business Specials
    • Oil/Gas Reports
      • FAAC Reports
      • Revenue
  • Health
    • COVID-19
    • News Reports
    • Special Reports and Investigations
    • Data and Infographics
    • Health Specials
    • Features
    • Events
    • Primary Health Tracker
  • Agriculture
    • News Report
    • Research & Innovation
    • Data & Infographics
    • Special Reports/Investigations
    • Features
    • Interviews
    • Multimedia
  • Arts/Life
    • Arts/Books
    • Kannywood
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Nollywood
    • Travel
  • Sports
    • Football
    • More Sports News
    • Sports Features
    • Casino
      • iGaming
      • Non AAMS
      • non Gamstop casinos
      • Kasyna online
      • Beste online casinos
      • Top cazinouri online
    • Gokken
      • Beste Online Casino Nederland
    • Games
      • كازينو اون لاين
      • Geriausi kazino internetu
      • Онлайн казино Казахстан
  • #EndSARS Dashboard
  • AUN-PT Data Hub
  • Projects
    • Panama Papers
    • Paradise Papers
    • SuisseSecrets
    • Parliament Watch
    • AGAHRIN
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
  • PT Hausa
  • Become a PT Insider
  • DONATE
  • About Us
  • Dubawa NG
  • Advert Rates
  • PT Jobs
  • Digital Store
  • Contact Us

All content is Copyrighted © 2025 The Premium Times, Nigeria

Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading