In October, when President Muhammadu Buhari presented the 2020 Appropriation Bill before a joint session of the upper and lower Houses of the National Assembly, his proposal was an aggregate of ₦10.3 trillion.
However, when he signed the bill into law in December, after the National Assembly’s perusal, the new aggregate was about ₦10.6 trillion — a difference of about ₦264 billion.
The Senate Committee Chairman on Appropriation, Ibrahim Barau, who first made this known, said the increase was targeted at offsetting the infrastructural deficit in the country.
Nonetheless, analysis of the add-ons obtained by PREMIUM TIMES has shown that the Federal Capital Territory Authority (FCTA) is the most favoured institution in the increments across Ministries, Departments and Agencies.
Mr Buhari initially budgeted ₦28.4 billion for the FCTA but upon passage, its new capital expenditure was increased to ₦62.41 billion.
In spite of the infrastructural rot bedeviling the capital city, renovation of the National Assembly complex would chalk off ₦37 billion from this.
Thus, for the coming year, renovation of the legislature building would gulp more funds than the entire stretch of the federal roads in the country would get.
Next to FCTA is the Universal Basic Education (UBE) Commission. Its capital allocation, which falls under the category of statutory transfers, got a raise of about ₦21.6 billion — up from ₦4.6 billion to ₦26.2 billion.
The increment is billed to cater for a flurry of vague projects inserted by federal lawmakers.
These include the “supply of instructional materials to various schools in the North-east,” priced at ₦500 million, same as the “supply of laptops and writing materials to schools in Borno State.”
In terms ratio of increase, the presidency’s Office of the Senior Special Assistant on MDGS (OSSAP-MDGS) took the lead.
The capital expenditure of the office which was initially ₦34 million is now ₦5.1 billion.
What the over ₦5 billion increment is for, among others, includes “supply of goods, fertilisers rice, maize and beans in Katsina” and “supply of tricycles, motorcycles, sewing machines,” each of which will cost ₦500 million; as well as “supply of new Toyota Hiace buses, utility vehicles SDG intervention,” which would gulp ₦1.9 billion.
The Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) in its recent report categorised projects of these nature — capacity building and empowerment programmes as they are called — as “free money without accountability, aside from being difficult to track.”
An analysis done by this newspaper on the other projects tucked under the budgets of other institutions by federal lawmakers also showed that a slew of them are the same controversial projects that the ICPC recommended be suspended from the nation’s budgetary system.
Like last year, when over 391 projects were smuggled by federal lawmakers into the budgets of the Small and Medium Enterprise Development Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN) and Border Communities Development Agency (BCDA), this year too, over 300 projects found their ways into the two agency’s budgets.
The said ICPC report singled out these two agencies as “conduits for embezzling funds” because of the size, type and number of projects domiciled under them.
This is notwithstanding the fact that some projects in both agencies are overpriced.
Changed presidential stance
When federal lawmakers, while exercising their power over the budget document last year, altered the initial proposal by adding over ₦500 billion and 6,000 new projects, the president was unimpressed and reacted quickly. Not so this time around.
That was a time when the relationship between the legislature and the executive was at an impasse. Then, the president chided the legislators for hijacking the executive’s role of proposing projects.
Mr Buhari, who is now serving his second and final term in office, said then that the funds for some necessary projects have been cut and some unnecessary ones got a raise.
“The National Assembly made cuts amounting to N347 billion in the allocations to 4,700 projects submitted to them for consideration and introduced 6,403 projects of their own amounting to N578 billion.
“Many of the projects cut are critical and may be difficult, if not impossible, to implement with the reduced allocation. Some of the new projects inserted by the National Assembly have not been properly conceptualised, designed and costed and will therefore be difficult to execute.
|FEDERAL COLLEGE OF FISHERIES AND MARINE TECHNOLOGY - LAGOS||996849602||6520757122||5523907520|
|FEDERAL CO-OPERATIVE COLLEGE- OJI RIVER||1054050828||3991348287||2937297459|
|NIGERIA STORED PRODUCTS RESEARCH, ILORIN||4190987497||7290438122||3099450625|
|NIGERIA INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGRAPHY AND MARINE RESEARCH||1306549336||5619102810||4312553474|
|FEDERAL CAPITAL TERRITORY ADMINISTRATION||28422804431||62407154360||33984349929|
|TRADE AND INVESTMENT||0|
|SMALL AND MEDIUM ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT AGENCY OF NIGERIA||11021125886||14850133832||3829007946|
|BORDER COMMUNITES DEVELOPMENT AGENCY||3731423484||9192685410||5461261926|
|NATIONAL BOUNDARY COMMISSION||440975845||973927053||532951208|
|LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT||0|
|NATIONAL DIRECTORATE OF EMPLOYMENT||1024786554||13998547226||12973760672|
|MINISTRY OF HUMANITARIAN AFFAIRS, DISASTER MANAGEMENT||0|
|NATIONAL AGENCY FOR THE PROHIBITION OF TRAFFIC IN PERSONS||33878667||1183878667||1150000000|
|NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR REFUGEE||1111252285||6120165930||5008913645|
|OFFICE OF THE SENIOR SPECIAL ASSISTANT TO THE PRESIDENT - MDGS (OSSAP-MDGS)||34006614||5106306283||5072299669|
|SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY||0|
|PROJECT DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE - ENUGU||5061984670||9546984670||4485000000|
|NIGERIAN BUILDING AND ROAD RESEARCH INSTITUTE - LAGOS||9311610090||20653380834||11341770744|
|ENERGY COMMISSION OF NIGERIA||1180610044||7817610044||6637000000|
|FEDERAL MINISTRY OF WATER RESOURCES||0|
|ANAMBRA/ IMO RBDA||3385626000||4572159700||1186533700|
|BENIN/ OWENA RBDA||2988204800||3118794560||130589760|
|CHAD BASIN RBDA||2573520000||3487844000||914324000|
|CROSS RIVER RBDA||2800702843||4432962701||1632259858|
|LOWER BENUE RBDA||4106488000||6467653735||2361165735|
|LOWER NIGER RBDA||2876888975||3846544526||969655551|
|OGUN/ OSUN RBDA||1075693366||3916908698||2841215332|
|SOKOTO RIMA RBDA||2356309292||5581309260||3224999968|
|UPPER BENUE RBDA||2662130542||3416772135||754641593|
|UPPER NIGER RBDA||1432869440||3966053920||2533184480|
|UNIVERSAL BASIC EDUCATION (UBE) COMMISSION||4605481710||26179251738||21573770028|
2020 Budget Analysis.xlsx
“Furthermore, many of these new projects introduced by the National Assembly have been added to the budgets of most MDAs with no consideration for institutional capacity to execute them or the incremental recurrent expenditure that may be required,” a displeased Mr Buhari said.
With the relationship between the two arms of government now ‘cordial’, the president simply heaped praises on the National Assembly for passing the budget in record time.
This is in spite of obvious concerns according to an analysis of the 2019 budget, for which the legislators were reproached.
“It is my pleasant duty, today, on my 77th birthday, to sign the 2020 Appropriation Bill into law.
“I’m pleased that the National Assembly has expeditiously passed this Bill. Our Federal Budget is now restored to a January-December implementation cycle,” pleased this time around, Mr Buhari wrote on his Twitter page.