SHOCKING: Firms facing trial for multi-billion subsidy fraud to lift Nigerian crude in 2017

oando

The list of companies released by the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation for the 2017/2018 crude oil trade includes some firms facing criminal charges for fuel subsidy fraud, PREMIUM TIMES can report.

The oil subsidy regime between 2009 – 2011 recorded one of the most monumental cases of fraud in Nigeria’s history, with the government paying importers subsidy for 59 million litres of fuel per day, while the country actually consumed about 35 million litres.

In 2011, Nigeria spent N2.5 trillion on fuel subsidy, a 900 percent increase from the N245 billion in the year’s budget.

More than 30 companies were identified after investigations were launched, and several of them are still facing criminal charges in Nigerian courts for making hugely inflated subsidy claims.

Last week, the NNPC released the names of 39 winners for the sale and purchase of Nigerian crude in 2017/2018. The contract would run for one year effective from January 1 for consecutive 12 circles of crude oil allocation and involves 18 Nigerian companies, 11 International Traders, five foreign refineries, three National Oil Companies (NOCs) and two NNPC trading arms.

The NNPC said all the contracts for the 2017/2018 crude trade were for 32,000 barrels per day except Duke Oil Ltd, an oil trading arm of the NNPC, which shall be for 90,000 barrels per day.

The indigenous beneficiaries include Oando, Sahara Energy, MRS Oil and Gas, AA Rano, Bono, Masters Energy, Eterna Oil and Gas, Cassiva Energy, Hyde Energy and Brittania U.

Others are NorthWest Petroleum, Optima Energy, AMG Petroenergy, Arkiren Oil and Gas Limited, Shoreline Limited, Entourage Oil, Setana Energy and Prudent Energy.

At least six of the companies were fingered in fuel subsidy fraud or are still facing charges over the matter.

These include Masters Energy, Oando, Eterna Oil and Gas, Seterna Energy, AMG Petroenergy, and Prudent Energy.

“Many of these multinationals, oil companies, and other high-level investors in the system, they have a way of manipulating the system that you won’t be surprised if many of them also have contributed to the campaign and funding of some of these political parties and government officials,” said Olanrewaju Suraju, chairman of Civil Society Network Against Corruption, a coalition of anti-corruption organisations.

“So they pay them back which is usually considered an investment in the electoral process. They get to pay them back with these kinds of contracts.”

ACCUSED OF FRAUD

On October 19, 2011, a vessel, MT Zhen Star, purportedly docked on Nigerian waters with 58,000 metric tonnes of petrol owned by two companies – Masters Energy Oil and Gas Limited and Caades Oil and Gas Limited, according to findings by a technical committee set up by the Nigerian government in 2012 to investigate subsidy payments.

Masters Energy claimed it discharged 28,000 metric tonnes of petrol from the vessel in the presence of officials of the Petroleum Products Pricing Regulatory Agency, Department of Petroleum Resources, Navy, Customs, and others.

In reality, however, MT Zhen Star does not exist, but Masters Energy collected N2.9 billion as subsidy claims from the Nigerian government, the committee concluded. Despite the indictment, Masters Energy was among some other indicted firms that were never prosecuted.

Also, in 2013, the Police Special Fraud Unit charged Oando Plc alongside three other companies and two managing directors for allegedly obtaining N2.9 billion from the federal government under false pretence of importing petroleum products into the country.

For Eterna Oil and Gas Plc, after initially arraigning them in 2012, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, EFCC, in 2014 re-arraigned the firm and its director, Mahmud Tukur, son of former chairman of the Peoples’ Democratic Party, alongside other suspects over a N3.1 billion fuel subsidy scam. The accused persons were charged on a 38-amended count charge bordering on conspiracy, obtaining money under false pretence and forgery.

Also in 2012, a House of Representatives committee led by Farouk Lawan named AMG Petroenergy, Setana Energy, and Prudent Energy in a list of 68 oil marketers that collected subsidy funds from the federal government illegally. The committee mandated the three companies to refund the sums of N7.2 billion, N2.7 billion, and N1.3 billion respectively to the Nigerian government.

Prudent Energy, which failed to appear before the committee, was also listed among marketers that were not registered with the PPPRA before they got their first allocation for product supplies. The company received its first allocation on August 12, 2011, ten days before it registered with the PPPRA, the lawmakers found.

The House committee listed Setana Energy as a marketer that had no tank-farm, never used its through-put agreement yet used it to claim N2.7 billion as fee for importation of 44.8 million litres of petroleum products under the Petroleum Support Fund (PSF) scheme.

The trio of AMG Petroenergy, Eterna Oil, and Prudent Energy and Resources Ltd were also listed as tax defaulters under the PSF scheme.

In 2009, the Accountant-General’s office paid N999 million each for 128 subsidy payments in a record-breaking 24 hours, an equivalent of about N42 million paid out every hour. The companies that benefitted include Oando Plc, N25.9 billion (26 cheques); Brittania U Nigeria Ltd, N999 million (one cheque); and NorthWest Petroleum, N8.9 billion (nine cheques).

The PPPRA had, however, explained at the time that the financial regulation at that period barred government agencies from issuing cheques of N1 billion and above.

“At the period of the payment approval, the marketers listed were owed several billions cumulatively and as such payments were broken down to N999 million per cheque in line with financial regulation.

While the technical committee, headed by Aig Imoukhuede, recommended that illegal payments made to oil marketers be recovered, the House committee called for the prosecution of fraudulent beneficiaries.

In the end, not all indicted marketers were prosecuted by the Nigerian government. For instance, Masters Energy, Setana Energy, Prudent Energy, and AMG Petroenergy were not charged to court.

INTERNATIONAL FIRM TOO

Trafigura Beheev BV (TBBV), one of the international beneficiaries of the crude lifting contract, had been involved in a crude oil swap agreement with the Nigerian government since 2010. The agreement saw the Pipelines and Products Marketing Company (PPMC) supply crude oil to the company in exchange for refined products.

But last year, the Federal Inland Revenue Service said the Amsterdam-based firm owed the Nigerian government $62.5 million (about N20 billion) in taxes from a 12.5 million metric tons crude oil swap worth $24 billion.

COMPANIES’ RESPONSE

PREMIUM TIMES reached out to all the companies indicted or charged for oil subsidy fraud included in the latest list of crude traders by the NNPC.

Setana Energy, Oando Plc, and AMG Petroenergy did not respond to e-mail enquiries.

Eterna Oil and Gas does not have a functional website.

A spokesperson for Prudent Energy, Kamil Adebumola, said the company was erroneously included in the list of marketers indicted for oil subsidy fraud and had been cleared of the allegations.

“Also, at no point did we import product under the PSF scheme without due application and approval from PPPRA,” Mr. Adebumola said in an emailed response to PREMIUM TIMES.

A spokesperson for Masters Energy also denied that the company was indicted in the oil subsidy scam.

“As a major player in the downstream operations of the oil and gas sector, we were invited like other marketers during the petroleum subsidy investigation, which we attended and satisfactorily made presentations on our various transactions during the period backed with relevant documents,” said Emma Iheanacho, the company’s Head of Corporate Communications.”

“We were thereafter cleared by SFU and EFCC.”

Last year, Trafigura had denied the FIRS accusation of tax evasion, noting that it chartered vessels for the purpose of delivering refined products to PPMC and taking delivery of the corresponding swap of crude oil at the designated ports.

“TBBV did not import petroleum products into the country as PPMC was responsible for all inward customs clearance and importation,” the company said in a statement on its website.

“Neither TBBV – nor any of its subsidiaries – has an office in Nigeria or staff (employees or third parties) locally acting on behalf of TBBV. No inventory was kept onshore and/or bonded storage. In the absence of these, both under Nigerian and international tax law TBBV has no obligation to register for tax purposes in Nigeria. As a result, the company does not have an income tax or any other tax obligation in Nigeria.”

‘BUSINESS AS USUAL’

Nigeria had only five fuel importers in 2006. One year later, the number rose to 10. In 2008, the figure grew to 19, and by 2011, it reached 140.

In 2013, under then president Goodluck Jonathan, the country widened the number of its fuel importers and included those indicted in the fuel subsidy investigations, angering government’s critics and opposition.

President Muhammadu Buhari defeated Mr. Jonathan in the 2015 election on the back of a campaign promise to tackle widespread corruption, especially in the petroleum industry.

Activists say the latest move to include indicted oil marketers among those to purchase and lift crude oil means not much has changed.

“If the EFCC is yet to issue a clean bill of health to those oil companies that were found wanting in the oil subsidy scam and the government is already engaging them for the same services that they, in the past, were stealing from the government and the people of Nigeria, then it is also saying that it is still business as usual,” said Mr. Suraju.

But the spokesperson of the NNPC, Ndu Ughamadu, said the government does not have any reason to blacklist any oil marketer because the charges against them are still before the courts.

“If proceedings are still in court and there are no injunctions that company A should be temporarily barred from doing certain things, the organisation is not obliged. They are still in court, and their filling stations are all over the place and they’ve been importing products for the country and in the interest of the country.” said Mr. Ughamadu.

“If the court puts an injunction on a particular company and the NNPC is served, maybe as the major stakeholder that deals with that particular company, NNPC is a corporate entity and we abide by all the rules and regulations of the country and all the injunctions of the courts.”

Wilson Uwujaren, the EFCC spokesperson, said most of the people investigated and charged for subsidy scam by the Commission are still in court.

“Even though it’s people who are charged, they are still doing business, the fact that you are charged does not mean that you will stop your business,” Mr. Uwujaren said.

“Even if you are a criminal, you have a criminal charge in court it doesn’t mean that once you are charged to court you abandon your businesses, you can do your business and face your charge in court.”


DOWNLOAD THE PREMIUM TIMES MOBILE APP

Now available on

  Premium Times Android mobile applicationPremium Times iOS mobile applicationPremium Times blackberry mobile applicationPremium Times windows mobile application

TEXT AD:Discover!!New Solution Helps Men Get Bigger Penis size!!To 7inch without Side Effect and Last 25minutes in bed During Sex Click Here To Read...


TEXT AD:WARNING TO MEN: These 3 Foods are Killing Your Erection. Click Here to Know Them...


All rights reserved. This material and any other material on this platform may not be reproduced, published, broadcast, written or distributed in full or in part, without written permission from PREMIUM TIMES.


  • new republic

    Nigeria is not a country,poor will continue to suffer if they don’t revolt.

  • Dazmillion

    Anyone who still thinks Buhari is fighting corruption should quickly check himself into the nearest psychiatric hospital for urgent mental evaluation.

    • Sanssouci

      If this had happened under Fortunato we would have never heard the end of it….how will suspected criminals not get oil lifting contracts when Abba Kyari is on NNPC board?

    • share Idea

      Thanks for coming back to your senses. When we the WAILERS complained that Bhari was never fighting corruption rather was fighting opposition, you people thought we were clueless and vindictive of Buhari, now that the scale of deceit is falling off your eyes, it will be nice you help spread your salvation message to your fellow APC e-mob. Nigeria we hail thee

      • Say the truth

        Dazmillion is just waking up to reality. He is among the most confused supporters of Buhari. All these hailing hailers are hypnotized zombies just supporting for the sake of it. Thank goodness the e-rats and online hyenas are coming to their senses. Wahala and Dazmillion welcome to real world.

        • Dazmillion

          I dont know how you came to the conclusion that I was a supporter of Buhari

      • Dazmillion

        I always had my senses friend. I dont support Buhari, neither am I a WAILER

  • Ncustom Akhigbe

    +2347035322790..CUSTOM IMPOUNDED CARS FOR SALES AT CHEAPER PRICE AND NCS REPLACEMENT FORM IS ALSO AVAILABLE FOR SALE, INTERESTED BUYERS SHOULD PLEASE. CONTACT OUR MARKETING ZONAL OFFICER (CUSTOM STELLA ON 07035322790..

  • Ncustom Akhigbe

    +2347035322790 BREAKING NEWS!! CLEAN VEHICLEs F0R SALE
    AT AFF0RDABLE PRICES AND IN A G00D W0RKING,
    RECRUITMENT FORM IS OUT FOR SALES C0NDITI0N

  • Dän-gote cémènt fâctōry

    PURCHASE CEMENT
    DIRECT FROM THE FACTORY
    FOR A PROMO PRICE OF #1,300 PER BAG
    AND #300 TO DELIVER PER BAG
    BUYERS CAN ORDER A MINIMUM OF 100BAGS,TRAILER LOAD OF 600BAGS,TRAILER LOAD OF 900BAGSS AND ABOVE,CONTACT THE SALES MANAGER MR AMUNE ON (0-8-0-36-90-93-83) OR ASSISTANT SALES MANAGER MRS OIZA ON (0-8-0-60-47-89-98) FOR BOOKING

  • westman

    Ok o.
    While some are being scammed because of false promise of 1000% return in 20 minutes. We are making cool cash in Ultimate cycler. Our Group is acclaimed the best Ultimate Cycler group in Nigeria. I registered 5days ago and I just got paid 50k today. Ultimate cycler is tested,tried and trusted. Register with our group today and make cool cash. Whatsapp +2348063667191

  • Rommel

    The slow pace of dispensing justice and compromised jurisprudence is part of the problem facing Nigeria in the fight against corruption in Nigeria,records have shown clearly that the administration of Goodluck Jonathan was more corrupt than all previous administrations put together including the colonial times and we need a clear departure from that,however,moving forward,we must ensure that things that happened under that inglorious administration are never repeated.

    • Odinaka

      Was Jonathan president between 2009 and 2011? You people are just funny. Instead of tackling the root cause of the problem, you are, like all APCs, demonising an individual.

      • Rommel

        President Yar’adua died 5th May 2010 after more than 8 months of incommunicado of president Jonathan presiding,maybe it was your father that was sworn in on that day

    • emmanuel

      Maggot, address the issue at stake.
      A robber is arrested, granted bail while the trial is on, then the Government make him the head of a revenue generation Agency and you call that slow dispensation of justice? You and your principals need psychiatrist examination.
      The APC is a big error and your role in their fold is to set Nigeria back. what a shame. I will not be shocked if you are a serial yahoo guy employed by the APC to do the dirty job online

      • Rommel

        The oil subsidy regime between 2009 – 2011 recorded one of the most monumental cases of fraud in Nigeria’s history, with the government paying importers subsidy for 59 million litres of fuel per day, while the country actually consumed about 35 million litres.

        In 2011, Nigeria spent N2.5 trillion on fuel subsidy, a 900 percent increase from the N245 billion in the year’s budget. Nigeria had only five fuel importers in 2006. One year later, the number rose to 10. In 2008, the figure grew to 19, and by 2011 under president Jonathan,it reached 140.

        But the spokesperson of the NNPC, Ndu Ughamadu, said the government does not have any reason to blacklist any oil marketer because the charges against them are still before the courts.
        “If proceedings are still in court and there are no injunctions that company A should be temporarily barred from doing certain things, the organisation is not obliged. They are still in court, and their filling stations are all over the place and they’ve been importing products for the country and in the interest of the country.” said Mr. Ughamadu

        • emmanuel

          There you go mumunatu, why then do your Buhari attempt to end the lives of opposition perceived offenders when they are still in Court? why does he incacerate others for cases in Court? Why have you asked that Bukola Saraki the crook be dropped while he still in Court?
          Are you no more Rommel? Do you forget so soon your various post?
          You are a sadist like your Buhari god

    • Otile

      Ungrateful parasite, what is new?

      • Rommel

        Just stating the facts

  • emmanuel

    Jonathan, why are you doing this to Nigeria? Licence crroks to generate revenue for you?
    Na wa for this corrupt Jonathan and Okonjo Iweala.
    For real, APC, Buhari and their followers are backward fifle.
    Punch, SR, PT, The Nation, TVC, The Sun, The Telegraph what is the headlines? how do you intend to kill this issue?
    You all though you did Jonathan in, but rather you killed your destiny.
    I have seen some TVC vehicles in recent times and they were in sorry state. Na God dey judge all of una.
    Where is Onike, Kay Soyemi, Tundemess, Aminu, Omo Musin, Comfortkay, etc? Wahala who graduated to holy wahala? i do not care if any of you repented from the confussion in the land. You are a victim of your indiscretion.

    • Otile

      Useless blame game from a dishonest parasite.

      • Otile

        Emmanuel,

        My brother, please disregard the comment, it is meant for parasitic Rommel.

        • Rommel

          See how confused you are,first you attacked Emmanuel who happens to be another of your kind that thrives on untruths thinking it was me and then you apologize to yourself hoping it is Emmanuel,perhaps you need to refill your medication,it is obviously running out

          • emmanuel

            i did not take offence at the post, because i can differentiate dishonest men from real men. Rommel is a sore looser, inspite of the fact that your Principals are in power, but lack what it takes to lead. They lead from the back which is reactionary leadership.
            Unfortunately thay have lackeys, scoudrels, spineless liars like you hired to launder their failed images which drowns every passing day.
            You are a despicable character that lacks integrity and thrives in confusion.
            What business would i have had with a leach like you if not for Lord Lugrd and the Political class from the South who have all failed in hrnessing quest for seperation? Go ask your wretched tribesmen from Chad, Niger, Mali, Senegal and Niger if i bother about their issues and reply to the post of their elite.
            Rommel – wether na Abdul, abi na usman; there is a time for everything and an end will come someday to our cohabitation

        • emmanuel

          Nothing spoil, i understand. Afterall, i don misfire you before too.

  • Say the truth

    This is how test if the government and indeed EFCC are really serious and sincere about the fight against corruption. All these companies are owned by some people WHY is the EFCC not making these cases a priority but was busy going after ‘enemies’ of the government alone. Magu remains a bull dog against opposition and he is not ready to fight corruption accross board.

  • Rumournaire

    Exactly which companies were indicted for subsidy fraud? I looked at the list in this story and it simply lists all companies that received subsidy from the government, whether fraudulent or not. But I recall that not all companies that received subsidy were indicted for fraud on same. Where, for instance, was Oando indicted? I do not work for Oando and have no relatives there, but I know they received large subsidy because they were the next biggest importer of petrol after NNPC. However, I do not recall them being accused of fraud. I think it is dishonest to suggest that every company that received subsidy for importing fuel at the request of the government was fraudulent.

    • emmanuel

      That is why you are rumornaire. The bribe given by Oando to cover up their thievery did not hold water. You only know who was not indicted.
      There were different layers of investigation on the scam and not all got bribed. Oando was involved

      • Rumournaire

        So basically, you suggest that all companies mentioned as having possibly be involved in the scam should have been excluded from this crude lifting contracting. If the mere possibility of having been involved would be enough to exclude them (as most of them were never established as having been involved; those proved are in court), can someone draw up a list of companies that should have got the lifting contracts? It would seem that none of the known indigenous companies should get the lifting contracts then, because there wasn’t any of them not mentioned as having collected subsidy money.

  • Dualpolemedia

    If all this indicted companies are been suspended from doing business with the government, and if a deliberate (artificial) scarcity of petroleum products hit the country, what would have been the reaction of the WAILERS? Probably, that the President is clueless and has no economic blueprint. Has anyone thought of or consider a deadly blow it will dealt with the economy if all this oil majors with strong financial muscles are barred from doing businesss? You can’t sanction a corporate entity by winding down their interests, while I will not be a party to corruption whosoever indicted should be made to face the law.

  • Abada

    Lift Nigeria’s oil? Does Nigeria have oil? Is it the oil of the Union of the Socialist Republics of Bight of Biafra and the Niger Delta that you are calling Nigeria’s oil? Don’t worry. When Avengers start and conclude OPERATION WALL OF JERICHO & HURRICANE JOSHUA we shall know who owns the oil.